Americans for Peace Now strongly opposes any move by the Trump Administration to alter longstanding US policy on Jerusalem outside the context of a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians. Here is what you need to know:
- 1. President Trump made a landmark announcement on Jerusalem on December 6th.
President Trump did two things in his speech: he reversed 70 years of American policy by recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and he announced plans to move the US embassy in Israel from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.
- 2. Recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, without any acknowledgment of Palestinian claims to Jerusalem, is the root of the problem.
Jerusalem is Israel’s capital. But the timing of international, and particularly American, recognition of this matters – as do the particular borders of Jerusalem that are recognized. The reason is that Palestinians also have legitimate claims to Jerusalem as the capital of their eventual state and any realistic peace plan includes at least some portion of East Jerusalem as that capital.
Moving the US embassy to Jerusalem, in the absence of a peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians, recognizes Israeli claims to Jerusalem while giving the Palestinians nothing. And timing matters. Trump’s impending announcement is occurring as Congress prepares to cut, through the Taylor Force Act, aid that would benefit the Palestinian Authority, and following Trump’s near-decision to close the PLO mission to Washington. (Since Trump's announcement, PA President Mahmoud Abbas recalled Palestinian diplomats in protest.) Adding to that, US recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and/or relocation of the US embassy creates a “triple whammy” against the Palestinians. It will severely damage American credibility as an honest broker of peace between Israelis and Palestinians, and in foreign policy more broadly. So much for President Trump’s avowed desire to make the “ultimate deal.”
--On Mako-Channel 12 Website, commentator Michal Yisraeli responds to the statement by TV presenter Avri Gilad that Jews sometimes need to be violent towards innocent Palestinians.*
You Must Be Kidding:
In an attempt to brand Israel in an original, new way in the world, an Israeli PR company has brought six celebrity dogs from North America, who have thousands of followers each on social media, to participate in a doggy vacation in Israel.**
The world holds its breath as President Trump prepares to unveil his administration's new policy on Jerusalem. Will he move the US embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem? Will the US recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital? What are the implications for Israelis and Palestinians and the prospects for peace?
- APN's Debra Shushan in Haaretz: As Trump and Netanyahu Meet, Our Plea as Interfaith Leaders: Stop Boosting the Proponents of a Religious War
- APN's Debra Shushan in Haaretz: The Israeli 'Left' Is Gaslighting U.S. Jews Into Support for Trump on Jerusalem
- APN: Trump's Jerusalem Move Sabotages Prospects for Peace, Endangers Lives, Degrades US Leadership
- 7 Things You Should Know: Trump’s Decision on Jerusalem
- US Public Opinion on Embassy Move: Polling Graphic
- They Say/We Say on Jerusalem
- Yossi Alpher Analysis
- Organizations Specializing on Jerusalem:
- Americans for Peace Now
- Shalom Achshav (Peace Now)
- Terrestrial Jerusalem
- Ir Amim - Temple Mount Crisis Resource Page
- Further Recommended Reading:
- Peace Now: President Trump’s declaration on Jerusalem is Bad News for Israel; 12/6/17
- Jake Walles: A Capital Offense
- Gershom Gorenberg’s Capital Offense
- David Makovsky on Trump’s diplomatic challenge in framing his announcement
- Haaretz backgrounder: Jerusalem for Dummies: Why the World Doesn’t Recognize It as Israel’s Capital
- New York Times mini-video: Why Jerusalem is a Controversial Capital
- New York Times timeline: the history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in Jerusalem
- Vox: Trump’s plan to declare Jerusalem the capital of Israel will derail decades of US diplomacy
Yossi Alpher is an independent security analyst. He is the former director of the Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies at Tel Aviv University, a former senior official with the Mossad, and a former IDF intelligence officer. Views and positions expressed here are those of the writer, and do not necessarily represent APN's views and policy positions.
This week, Alpher discusses whether Trump will announce his decision to recognize Jerusalem as Israel's capital and whether this would spark the next intifada; the settlements issue as part of the Trump-Russia investigation; the 70th anniversary of the United Nations decision to partition Palestine and the Palestinians' and Arab countries' rejection of it in 1947; and whether the Netanyahu government should and could have intervened in Syria in 2012, toppled the Assad regime and installed the secular opposition in power.
—Co-founder of the Peres Center for Peace and the ‘Yallah - Young Leadership’ movement, Uri Savir, writes in an Op-Ed in Maariv, following the controversial remarks by Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Tzipi Hotovely.*
You Must Be Kidding:
Leading Sephardic Israeli rabbi bans followers from looking at new 50-shekel banknotes, which feature a Jewish Russian-Israeli poet who was married to a Christian.**
Produced by the Foundation for Middle East Peace in cooperation with Americans for Peace Now, where the Legislative Round-Up was conceived
Facts matter.
And they particularly matter when it comes to a respectable publication like Bloomberg.com and a reputable journalist such as Eli Lake.
In an article that discusses the Trump transition team’s apparent efforts to lobby foreign governments to veto a UN Security Council resolution critical of Israel from which the Obama administration abstained, Lake writes the following: “Even though the Obama administration had less than a month left in office, the president instructed his ambassador to the United Nations to abstain from a resolution, breaking a precedent that went back to 1980 when it came to one-sided anti-Israel resolutions at the UN.”
Haaretz: November 29, 2017
"Israeli Attorney General Seeks to Save Buildings in West Bank Outpost From
Demolition," After Peace Now wins Supreme Court petition, Israel's Attorney General seeks ways to save
illegal outpost homes from demolition.
Jerusalem Post: November 29, 2017
"AG weighs savings six settler outpost homes," Attorney General tries to save
settler outpost homes that Court ordered demolished after Peace Now won Supreme Court petition.
JewSchool (by American Jewish Peace Archive): November 26, 2017
"Israelis Rising Up: Remembering with Yuli Tamir and Janet Aviad," A tribute to
Peace Now and two of its founders.
Jerusalem Post: November 23, 2017
"IDF weighs new tool to legalize settler outposts," Peace Now's lawyer rejects
Israeli Attorney General's new tool for legalizing illegal outposts.
Times of Israel: November 22, 2017
"AG: Outpost law discriminates against Palestinians, should be repealed," Peace Now
criticizes Israeli AG decision to allow expropriating privately-owned Palestinian land for access road to
illegal outpost.
APN Director of Policy and Government Relations Debra Shushan in Haaretz: November 30, 2017
"David Friedman Is Unfit to Be U.S. Ambassador to Israel. Fire Him."
America has a problem in Tel Aviv.
The U.S. ambassador to Israel, David Friedman, has politicized his diplomatic office and misrepresented U.S. policy on Israel’s conflict with the Palestinians. In the process, he is causing real damage to our country’s interests in the region. Read More >
Washington Jewish Week: November 29, 2017
"Race is on for year-end giving," Like other small Jewish groups, APN is busy with
end-of-year fundraising efforts.
JTA: November 22, 2017
"Arab American groups offer PLO office space if it’s shut down," APN among groups
urging the Trump administration not to shut down PLO office in DC.