Israel Study Tour, A Report from the Ground

| 2 Comments
Study_Tour_Collage_186x140.jpgOn our first two days in Israel and West Bank, APN's study tour group saw East Jerusalem and Hebron, the two holiest towns to Judaism and, not coincidentally, the two predominantly Palestinian urban areas in which Israelis choose to settle.

The situation in both places is awful and getting worse every day. Both Jerusalem and Hebron offer a glimpse into what the future holds for all Israelis and Palestinians if they fail to reach a two state peace solution, if they allow the status quo to fester.

------------------------------------------
Pictures from the tour (clockwise): Peace Now Settlement Watch Director Hagit Ofran, Professor and Tour Leader Mark Rosenblum, Guest Speaker Mordecai Kremnitzer from the Israel Democracy Institute, Peace Now Director Yariv Oppenheimer.
------------------------------------------

In East Jerusalem, we saw how ideologically-motivated Jewish settlers, backed by the Netanyahu government, are settling in Palestinian neighborhoods around the historic basin. The settlers and their supporters are trying to create a ring of Israeli strongholds around the Historic Basin in the hope of preventing any future effort to divide Jerusalem. Hagit Ofran of Peace Now and Danny Seidemann, the utmost experts on Jerusalem, took us on a "connect-the-dots" tour around the Old City of Jerusalem, showing us settler strongholds in Sheikh Jarrah, the Mount of Olives, and Silwan. Each one of these friction spots might ignite a fire that would not only scorch this holy city and its surroundings, but would very likely send flames throughout the Middle East and beyond.

Hebron_Silwan_300.jpg

In downtown Hebron, we saw how the market that used to the 170,000 Palestinian residents of the city and dozens of adjacent villages has been taken over by several hundreds of Israeli settlers. We met with members of TIPH, the Temporary International Presence in Hebron. This unarmed force of international observers was first established in the mid 1990s, following the Oslo accords, to help reduce friction between Israelis and Palestinians in Hebron. These European observers have become a part of the bizarre landscape in Hebron. We asked one of them, a Swedish volunteer, how The Palestinians and the settlers treat them. The Palestinians are appreciative, he said, the settlers don't speak to them, and the children on both sides throw rocks at them.

We met Issa Amro, a Palestinian activist. He is trying to organize demonstrations against the closure of downtown Hebron to Palestinian traffic (and, for the most part, to Palestinian pedestrians as well). He is currently trying to bring to Hebron an exhibit created by Breaking the Silence, a group composed of Israeli veterans to draw attention to their experiences as occupiers in the West Bank. It turns out that the organization, which was started because of the soldiers' experiences in Hebron, has shown its exhibit almost everywhere but in Hebron.

We met with the US Consul General in Jerusalem, Daniel Rubinstein, and with the Washington Post's Jerusalem bureau chief, Janine Zacharia. We also met with Israel's leading political columnist Nahum Barnea, of Yedioth Ahronoth. All three, separately, spoke about the impact of events in Egypt on Israeli-Palestinian relations.

On Tuesday night, we met with Israel's leading constitutional law expert, Professor Mordechai Kremnitzer of the Israel Democracy Institute (IDI). Kremintzer told us how the Institute, a think tank, found itself acting as an advocacy organization in recent months, desperately working to block Knesset bills that chip away at Israel's democratic character. He mentioned a couple of current bills that the Knesset is likely to consider soon. One of us made the mistake of asking for more examples. It triggered an avalanche. Interestingly, Kremnitzer said that the IDI is making tremendous efforts to recruit America's organized Jewish community to raise its voice against some of the bills and against the overall trend. Several American Jewish groups have. Other important ones refuse. Most refuse, as a matter of principle, to criticize official Israeli policies even if these policies are detrimental to Israel's future, Kremnitzer lamented. Welcome to APN's world.

In the coming days we will have a chance to talk about these issues with members of the Israeli cabinet and with Knesset members.

Later this week we will meet with Palestinian leaders in Ramallah.

2 Comments

Thanks for standing up to the Israeli Government, the Evangelicals and the Tea Party, in and out of Congress.

P.S. I am Jewish,

Agree the Boundry. Israelis allowed to remain in palestine must become Permanent Residents. Protect and build The 'Arc' [Pal transport and communications corridor]. Relocate all willing Pals
from Israel to Palestine. Appeal to UN to station Peacekeeping and Police Forces in Palestine. Stress reform, no-nonsense laws and civil progress. Establish Ports-of-Entry with checks on both sides to prevent weapons/bombs crossing. New, no-nonsense capital campus for three branches [Exec, Legislative, Judicial] and fulltime Peoples Reps in the Unicameral, non-partisan, concensus govt. Palestine becomes like New England and US Southwest. Adopts Euro as currency and makes most financial/banking/etc. transactions electronic. Cooperative 'Pal-Markets' allow nice shopping sites of appropriate size for the Palestinian communities...Aaron Allen...

Leave a comment

Ori Nir
Ori N.

Ori Nir is a Person for Peace

Ori Nir
Lara Friedman
Lara F

Lara Friedman is a Person for Peace

Lara Friedman
Rabbi Alana Suskin
RabbiSuskin

Rabbi Alana Suskin is a Person for Peace

Rabbi Alana Suskin
Hagit Ofran
Hagit O

Hagit Ofran is a Person for Peace

Hagit Ofran
David Pine
David P

David Pine is a Person for Peace

David Pine
  • 5/10 1:16p Just heard Israeli writer Stuart Schoffman. Always great! Says instead of BDS, concern is PDD (polarization, demonization, denial)
News Nosh
see the APN "facts on the Ground" mapping application
Shalom Achshav

APN's direct connection to Israel

APN on Facebook