APN's daily news review from Israel
Tuesday September 06, 2016
Quote of the day:
"A country that every morning sends 17 inspectors to oversee the almost 14 thousand construction sites,
and they take the bus. A country that is in a frenzy of building more and more apartments and parking lot and
roads and interchanges on the backs of Arabs and Chinese. One inspector per 800 construction sites is a murder
weapon.”
--Radio 103FM talk show host, Gabi Gazit, reacts to the killing and injuring of laborers, most assumed to be Arab or foreigners, in a massive collapse at a construction site for a parking complex.*
You Must Be Kidding:
Seth Klarman, the American billionaire who cofounded The Times of Israel news website, has given more than $1.5 million to CAMERA, a right-wing media watchdog that attacks reports critical of Israel.**
--Radio 103FM talk show host, Gabi Gazit, reacts to the killing and injuring of laborers, most assumed to be Arab or foreigners, in a massive collapse at a construction site for a parking complex.*
You Must Be Kidding:
Seth Klarman, the American billionaire who cofounded The Times of Israel news website, has given more than $1.5 million to CAMERA, a right-wing media watchdog that attacks reports critical of Israel.**
Front Page:
Haaretz
- At least two people killed and five missing in collapse of parking complex in Tel-Aviv
- Power chasers abandoned the safety of the laborers // Or Kashti
- Deri advancing closure of all supermarkets in Tel-Aviv on Shabbat, without enforcement at three shopping centers
- Police raided Netanya Municipality; Mayor Feierburg expected to be questioned
- Owner of Israeli news website funded organization that attacks critical coverage of Israel
- Mayor of Julius shot dead a man with whom he had a dispute; claims it was self-defense
- They [Eritrean asylum seekers] deserve to be protected // Haaretz Editorial
- Only in China can one build the longest glass bridge in the world. Ask the Israeli architect
Yedioth Ahronoth
- Collapse
- New discoveries: CEO of company that is building the parking complex said three years ago at the start of the project: “Instead of an engineer, who is a technical person who is responsible that the building doesn’t fall, we took an architect to run the project. That’s how we saved in costs.”
Maariv This Week (Hebrew links only)
- The parking complex disaster
- Arab labor // Ben Caspit
Israel Hayom
- The parking complex oversight
- The construction industry must go through a safety and quality revolution // Prof. Yechiel Rosenfeld
- Knesset Labor and Welfare Committee to hold special meeting
- The stories of the wounded: “The blast blew my brother outside – he was saved by a miracle”
- Home Front command activated for the first time a radar system for locating cellular signals
News Summary:
Yedioth called it, ‘Ground Zero.’ The collapse yesterday of an enormous parking complex under construction in the Ramat Hahayal neighborhood of Tel-Aviv, has already claimed the lives of three construction workers (as of this writing) with at least four more still feared trapped under the rubble and over 20 injured. And with the usual exception of Israel Hayom, the newspapers asked hard questions that pointed to the state as guilty for not providing enough inspection and law enforcement of safety guidelines. The commentators wrote sharp criticism (See Commentary below), noting that the high number of deaths in the construction industry never concerned the state because Arabs and Foreigners make up most of the deaths, 90% of those killed on the job this year. Rescue workers continued through the night looking for the missing, among whom was Taleb Dawabsheh, a 29-year-old Palestinian from West Bank village of Duma, where a Jewish arsonists killed a family. Haaretz+ reported that the company operating the site has an alarming history of accidents and safety violations and Yedioth revealed that the CEO of the company boasted in 2013 that he was able to save 2–3% on building costs by using an architect as opposed to an engineer. Ynet has video from reporters who went in with the rescue workers. Workers at the site said that they warned that the site could collapse; 'We felt the ground shaking. Within an hour, the whole place collapsed.' Numerous Palestinian construction workers were among the 24 injured.
In other news, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu discussed with a Russian envoy about holding a meeting with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in Moscow. Abbas reportedly agreed to the talks with Netanyahu
And former Palestinian Prime Minister in Gaza, Ismail Haniyeh, reportedly was chosen as Hamas' new Political Bureau Chief, to replace Khaled Meshal at the end of the year. Meanwhile, Haniyeh left the Gaza Strip for the first time since 2013 with other Hamas leaders and security guards to attend the Haj. He will hold talks in Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Turkey before returning to Gaza.
And as has been so common with the Hebrew media, reporters took as fact the Border Police report that the Palestinian they shot dead in a car at night was intending to ram into them. None of the Hebrew media reporters bothered to get the Palestinian side of the story. However, Maan interviewed witnesses, spoke with his mother and took photos from the scene and revealed a different story of two young relatives in a car which came under live fire while driving near clashes that erupted between local youth and Israeli soldiers during a military raid in Shufat refugee camp. The car was riddled with bullets even after it stopped, killing Mustafa Nimr, 27, and wounding his brother-in-law. Nimr’s mother said that she had spoken to Nimr on the phone as he drove back home. “He said they were bringing us food and new clothes for Ali’s daughter,” she told Ma’an, rejecting the claim that the two were planning a car ramming attack on Israeli soldiers. Pictures taken from inside the car after the incident show the back seat sprayed with blood -- shopping bags and loaves of bread still sitting on the seat. Haaretz reported that Nimr was ‘suspected’ of intending to ram the Border Police – none of whom were hurt and all the other media wrote that a “terrorist was killed in an attempted ramming attack.”
Yedioth called it, ‘Ground Zero.’ The collapse yesterday of an enormous parking complex under construction in the Ramat Hahayal neighborhood of Tel-Aviv, has already claimed the lives of three construction workers (as of this writing) with at least four more still feared trapped under the rubble and over 20 injured. And with the usual exception of Israel Hayom, the newspapers asked hard questions that pointed to the state as guilty for not providing enough inspection and law enforcement of safety guidelines. The commentators wrote sharp criticism (See Commentary below), noting that the high number of deaths in the construction industry never concerned the state because Arabs and Foreigners make up most of the deaths, 90% of those killed on the job this year. Rescue workers continued through the night looking for the missing, among whom was Taleb Dawabsheh, a 29-year-old Palestinian from West Bank village of Duma, where a Jewish arsonists killed a family. Haaretz+ reported that the company operating the site has an alarming history of accidents and safety violations and Yedioth revealed that the CEO of the company boasted in 2013 that he was able to save 2–3% on building costs by using an architect as opposed to an engineer. Ynet has video from reporters who went in with the rescue workers. Workers at the site said that they warned that the site could collapse; 'We felt the ground shaking. Within an hour, the whole place collapsed.' Numerous Palestinian construction workers were among the 24 injured.
In other news, Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu discussed with a Russian envoy about holding a meeting with Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas in Moscow. Abbas reportedly agreed to the talks with Netanyahu
And former Palestinian Prime Minister in Gaza, Ismail Haniyeh, reportedly was chosen as Hamas' new Political Bureau Chief, to replace Khaled Meshal at the end of the year. Meanwhile, Haniyeh left the Gaza Strip for the first time since 2013 with other Hamas leaders and security guards to attend the Haj. He will hold talks in Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Turkey before returning to Gaza.
And as has been so common with the Hebrew media, reporters took as fact the Border Police report that the Palestinian they shot dead in a car at night was intending to ram into them. None of the Hebrew media reporters bothered to get the Palestinian side of the story. However, Maan interviewed witnesses, spoke with his mother and took photos from the scene and revealed a different story of two young relatives in a car which came under live fire while driving near clashes that erupted between local youth and Israeli soldiers during a military raid in Shufat refugee camp. The car was riddled with bullets even after it stopped, killing Mustafa Nimr, 27, and wounding his brother-in-law. Nimr’s mother said that she had spoken to Nimr on the phone as he drove back home. “He said they were bringing us food and new clothes for Ali’s daughter,” she told Ma’an, rejecting the claim that the two were planning a car ramming attack on Israeli soldiers. Pictures taken from inside the car after the incident show the back seat sprayed with blood -- shopping bags and loaves of bread still sitting on the seat. Haaretz reported that Nimr was ‘suspected’ of intending to ram the Border Police – none of whom were hurt and all the other media wrote that a “terrorist was killed in an attempted ramming attack.”
Quick Hits:
- Report: Israel detained 30 Palestinian teens in August, majority report being tortured - Israeli forces imprisoned 30 teenage Palestinians over the month of August and collected 65,000 shekels ($1,7270) from their families as fines, the Palestinian Committee of Prisoners’ Affairs said. The majority of the detainees said they were beaten and tortured during their detention, interrogation, and transport from one detention center to another. (Maan)
- Despite Court Decision, Jerusalem Has Not Built 2,000 Classrooms for Arab Neighborhoods - In 2011, High Court gave state five years to answer the public school shortage in East Jerusalem, yet only 237 classrooms have been added since. (Haaretz+)
- Relatives of hunger-striking Palestinian prisoners held by Israel march in Bethlehem - Palestinian Committee of Prisoners’ Affairs said that the large numbers participating in the march was a message to hunger-striking prisoners that “they were not alone in their fight against administrative detention (prison without charges or trial).” (Maan)
- Defense Minister approves several condition-easing actions for Palestinians ahead of Eid al-Adha - Among the measures that were approved as part of a policy to improve the quality of life of the Palestinian population in the West Bank and Gaza Strip: visits to family in Israel, prayers on the Temple Mount and travel abroad via Ben Gurion Airport. [Note: this is approved annually. – OH] (Ynet and Maariv)
- Israeli groups seeks referendum on disputed territories - 'Decision 50', led by prominent figures in Israel's self-proclaimed peace camp, including Peace Now, has urged PM Netanyahu to call a nationwide referendum on whether Israel should withdraw from disputed territories; activists claim control over territories brings Israel closer to its end. (Agencies, Ynet)
- **Times of Israel Cofounder Gave $1.5 Million to Right-wing Media Watchdog That Routinely Goes After News Outlets - Seth Klarman's foundation gave $200,000 to Camera in 2012 - the same year Times of Israel was launched. That donation was one of at least nine annual contributions to Camera, financial reports reveal. (Haaretz)
- Trump Campaign Opens West Bank Office, as Republicans in Israel Declare Him Good for Settlers - The new makeshift office was proudly touted as the first U.S. campaign headquarters ever opened over the 'Green Line,' a reference to Israel’s internationally recognized borders. (Haaretz+ and Israel Hayom)
- Surgeon testifies: Azaria's shot didn't kill al-Sharif - Prof. Dov Shimon testified for the defense on Tuesday that the Hebron soldier's head shot to the immobilized terrorist was not what killed him, disagreeing with the pathologist who testified earlier. (Ynet)
- Palestinian restores 50 dunams of his land in Salfit from Israel after 12-year legal battle - Following a legal battle in international and local courts, Israel returned a total of 50 dunams (12.3 acres) of land were returned to a Palestinian resident of the village of al-Zawiya in the northern occupied West Bank that it had declared as “state land” 12 years earlier. (Maan)
- Israel Finds Structure That May Have Big Gas Reserves - Energy Ministry delegation in London in road show ahead of November license tender. (Haaretz+)
- Israeli Incarceration Figures Reveal Eruption in Arrest Rates, Legal Proceedings Over 17 Years - From 1998 to 2015, annual arrests rose from 38,000 to 62,000, while remands in police custody until end of legal proceedings soared from 6,000 to 20,000, says public defender’s report. (Haaretz+)
- From Russia with love: The 'Israeli exhibition' in Moscow - A cooperative project between the Israeli Ministry of Tourism in Moscow and National Geographic will see the display in Moscow of photos of Israel depicting the country's finest light; 'The people thank us for bringing the Israeli sun here. They say they want to visit Israel.' (Yedioth/Ynet)
- $4,380 Restaurant Tab for Tourists in Israel Sparks Social Media Outcry - Did the Abu Ghosh restaurant rip off eight Chinese diners — or was it simply providing a gourmet meal to match the bill? (Haaretz)
- Poll ranks Hebrew University No. 1 in Israel, 148th in the world - Quacquarelli Symonds' yearly university ranking keeps Hebrew University in 148th place in the world, first in Israel • University president: "Our academic reputation is an outcome of the faculty and students' hard work and commitment to excellence. (Israel Hayom)
- Iran and Britain Exchange Ambassadors for First Time Since 2011 - Though both countries reopened their embassies in 2015, they had been manned by charges d'affairs until now. 'I hope this will mark the start of more productive co-operation between our countries,' Britain's Boris Johnson says. (Agencies, Haaretz)
- Wave of bombings in Syria claimed by ISIS kills at least 48 - The Islamic State terrorist group claimed responsibility for the Monday attacks, which took place across war-torn Syria, including the city of Homs and suburbs of the capital Damascus. (Agencies, Ynet)
- Almost 2,000 Killed in Renewed Turkish-Kurdish Conflict, Rights Groups Say - At least 40 percent of the victims died in so-called 'urban curfew zones' in Turkey's southeast, which has seen renewed fighting after a fragile ceasefire collapsed in the summer of 2015. (Agencies, Haaretz)
Commentary/Analysis:
*The (parking complex) disaster is premeditated murder (Gabi Gazit, 103FM/Maariv) The State of Israel executed people who came to build it. It knew that
would happen and did nothing to prevent it. People were murdered by corrupt politicians and no one will go
to jail… Everything was prepared for this. There was a firing squad. There was a killing pit. There was an
incited mob shouting, ‘It’s good that Arabs died there, because, as we know, a good Arab is an Arab lying
under a pile of Jews’ dust. The State of Israel has killed these people, which so far have no name, no
face and no identity, just as cannon fodder for the glory of the functionaries. A country that every
morning sends 17 inspectors to oversee the almost 14 thousand construction sites, and they take the bus. A
country that is in a frenzy of building more and more apartments and parking lot and roads and
interchanges on the backs of Arabs and Chinese. One inspector per 800 construction sites is a murder
weapon.
There's Been Debate but It's Settled. Israel's PM Cares Only for His Political Survival (Uzi Baram, Haaretz+) Netanyahu doesn’t really care if work takes place on Shabbat or not, or whether migrant children study or are abandoned, or whether anyone studies English, math or science.
The labor was Arab, the oversight was Jewish: Bad Israeli culture brought the disaster in Ramat Hahayal (Ben Caspit, Maariv) The workers may be Arabs or Chinese, but the oversight that brought down the parking complex is Israeli, a kosher Mehadrin Jew: the oversight of negligence, of lack of professionalism, of contempt and of greed and of the culture of doing things carelessly. All this is under the auspices of the state: the state provided few inspectors, who received minimum wage and don’t even get reimbursement for expenses that would allow them to travel between 13 thousand construction sites across the country. They need to take the bus. And when they arrive, what they can do? Nothing and nothing. 230 deaths in the past five years, generating 11 indictments. Almost always an ambulance comes, takes away the body, someone sweeps up after it, cleans the blood stains, if any, and moves on. This culture (of carelessness) is common in many other fields. Road safety is a great example. What is happening in the field of heavy-duty trucks is the same. Look at the number of inspectors at construction sites and compare it with the number of traffic policemen. Exactly the same phenomenon. No budget, no manpower, it does not interest anyone. The bodies are piling up, and everything goes on as usual. In a few days the dust will settle over the parking complex at Ramat Hahayal. The debris will be removed. Assuming that the dead came from Ramallah or Wadi Ara (Arab Israeli area) or the Ukraine, they won’t make the newspaper’s weekend supplement. And then, you ask? Then everything will continue as normal.
Burying NIS 600 million in the ground (Alex Fishman, Yedioth/Ynet) The Israeli government is set to invest hundreds of millions in the initial phase of establishing a Gaza tunnel blockade. The problem is that there's no money allocated for the rest of the blockade; if the West Bank border fence is any indication, there never will be.
Has America Closed the Gates of Justice for Victims of Palestinian Terror? (Seth Lipsky, Haaretz+) With the quashing of the Sokolow case, we could now be at the end of a decades long strategy of using American civil law to hold accountable terrorists who kill Americans abroad.
We’re going to miss Obama: the president is good for Israel because he is good for America first (Uri Savir, Maariv) Obama is the kind of friend we need: not a president who will say ‘amen’ to every extremist whim of the Israeli government, but one that leads towards processes for the sake of the country's democratic identity.
Israel's Other Magician: Yair Lapid (Iris Leal, Haaretz+) Lapid’s message is clear and terrifying: A politician who wants a reasonable chance at becoming prime minister must be an empty screen onto which anyone can project their own wishes.
Playing the blame game (Nahum Barnea, Yedioth/Ynet) The question we should all be asking is not how the current train work crisis will be solved, but what the next battleground between the different factions in Israeli society will be and when—if ever—will it end.
Blame the West for ISIS? Yes - but Go Back to 1925 (Maya Wahrman, Haaretz+) In 2016, ISIS is asking Iraqis the same question (though brutally and violently) as the West’s bureaucrats did in 1925: Who belongs and who does not?
There's Been Debate but It's Settled. Israel's PM Cares Only for His Political Survival (Uzi Baram, Haaretz+) Netanyahu doesn’t really care if work takes place on Shabbat or not, or whether migrant children study or are abandoned, or whether anyone studies English, math or science.
The labor was Arab, the oversight was Jewish: Bad Israeli culture brought the disaster in Ramat Hahayal (Ben Caspit, Maariv) The workers may be Arabs or Chinese, but the oversight that brought down the parking complex is Israeli, a kosher Mehadrin Jew: the oversight of negligence, of lack of professionalism, of contempt and of greed and of the culture of doing things carelessly. All this is under the auspices of the state: the state provided few inspectors, who received minimum wage and don’t even get reimbursement for expenses that would allow them to travel between 13 thousand construction sites across the country. They need to take the bus. And when they arrive, what they can do? Nothing and nothing. 230 deaths in the past five years, generating 11 indictments. Almost always an ambulance comes, takes away the body, someone sweeps up after it, cleans the blood stains, if any, and moves on. This culture (of carelessness) is common in many other fields. Road safety is a great example. What is happening in the field of heavy-duty trucks is the same. Look at the number of inspectors at construction sites and compare it with the number of traffic policemen. Exactly the same phenomenon. No budget, no manpower, it does not interest anyone. The bodies are piling up, and everything goes on as usual. In a few days the dust will settle over the parking complex at Ramat Hahayal. The debris will be removed. Assuming that the dead came from Ramallah or Wadi Ara (Arab Israeli area) or the Ukraine, they won’t make the newspaper’s weekend supplement. And then, you ask? Then everything will continue as normal.
Burying NIS 600 million in the ground (Alex Fishman, Yedioth/Ynet) The Israeli government is set to invest hundreds of millions in the initial phase of establishing a Gaza tunnel blockade. The problem is that there's no money allocated for the rest of the blockade; if the West Bank border fence is any indication, there never will be.
Has America Closed the Gates of Justice for Victims of Palestinian Terror? (Seth Lipsky, Haaretz+) With the quashing of the Sokolow case, we could now be at the end of a decades long strategy of using American civil law to hold accountable terrorists who kill Americans abroad.
We’re going to miss Obama: the president is good for Israel because he is good for America first (Uri Savir, Maariv) Obama is the kind of friend we need: not a president who will say ‘amen’ to every extremist whim of the Israeli government, but one that leads towards processes for the sake of the country's democratic identity.
Israel's Other Magician: Yair Lapid (Iris Leal, Haaretz+) Lapid’s message is clear and terrifying: A politician who wants a reasonable chance at becoming prime minister must be an empty screen onto which anyone can project their own wishes.
Playing the blame game (Nahum Barnea, Yedioth/Ynet) The question we should all be asking is not how the current train work crisis will be solved, but what the next battleground between the different factions in Israeli society will be and when—if ever—will it end.
Blame the West for ISIS? Yes - but Go Back to 1925 (Maya Wahrman, Haaretz+) In 2016, ISIS is asking Iraqis the same question (though brutally and violently) as the West’s bureaucrats did in 1925: Who belongs and who does not?
Prepared for APN by Orly Halpern, independent freelance journalist based in Jerusalem.