Q. Does the absence of a Palestinian state threaten Israel? How?
A. Yes, it threatens Israel, and in more ways than one.
Without an Arab-state political affiliation for the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Israel is
universally seen as their occupier. Not a single state in the world recognizes the terms “Judea and Samaria” or
Israel’s annexation of East Jerusalem. The possibility of restoring a pre-1967 political link, say by
affiliating the West Bank in some way with Jordan, has ceased to be realistic in Arab eyes for several decades.
This is so despite the fact that some Israeli right-wingers cut off from regional realities and international
standards of human rights argue that West Bank Palestinians could enjoy autonomy under Israel and vote in
Jordanian elections.
Nor is the paternalistic proposal put forth by some on the Israeli right—to the effect that Palestinians in the
West Bank can in perpetuity enjoy “human” rights but not citizenship rights on the land where they live--
viable in the eyes of Palestinians or anyone else in the world. Palestinian Arabs today identify as
Palestinians in a political sense. If they cannot achieve sovereign statehood, the only fallback position they
are likely to recognize is Israeli citizenship within the framework of a single state.
This brings us to the demographic issue. Most demographers today argue that there are already more Arabs than
Jews in the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean. Some on the Israeli right argue that the
totality of Arabs is “only” 40 percent of the total population, meaning Jews constitute 55 percent (another
five percent of Israelis are neither Jewish nor Arab). In some cases this figure is achieved by ignoring the
two million Palestinians in the Gaza Strip, a highly problematic geopolitical determination. In other cases it
is achieved by radically underestimating the number of Palestinians in the West Bank and ignoring the 300,000
Palestinians in East Jerusalem.
One way or another, even an Israeli state with a 40 percent (and growing!) Arab minority cannot claim to be
intrinsically Jewish. As for a non-democratic state that favors its Jewish over its Arab inhabitants, this is
anathema to the vast majority of Jews, to say nothing of the international community. It places Israel in the
global family of racist, fascist countries whose prospects for enlightened progress are zero.